Skip to content
Promised vs. Delivered Memphis
Public records

Follow the promise to the proof.

A public scoreboard for tax incentive deals.

For Memphis residents. See what was promised and what the public records say was delivered.

Promised vs. Delivered

Memphis Scoreboard

$5 Buy
Not on sale right now
A laptop displaying tax incentive records, with the Memphis skyline and Mississippi River beyond.
Memphis / Shelby County Public money. Public questions.

From filing to finding

The announcement
is only the beginning.

Paper charts, a local map, a notebook and a pen laid out for reviewing public records.

The promise

Start with the filing.

Public PILOT filings record the deal. The scoreboard brings those commitments together so the original promise does not disappear behind the announcement.

Hands checking printed reports beside a monitor displaying civic data.

The delivery

Match it to the report.

Compliance reports supply the other side of the comparison. Matching what was promised to what was delivered is the tedious work that makes the records useful.

The finding

Keep the comparison
in public view.

The idea is a shareable card for each deal: a clear account of the company, the commitment and the outcome—with the documents behind it.

  • Company
  • Jobs promised
  • Jobs delivered
  • Taxes forgiven
  • Cost per actual job

Why Marcus is building it

The deal gets announced loudly.
Who checks the results?

Marcus runs Promised vs. Delivered to close the gap between a public promise and a public accounting.

Residents need numbers. Journalists and council candidates need evidence they can use. The starting point is Memphis: public PILOT filings and compliance reports, organized into a scoreboard.

Independent. Investigative. Document-led.

The scoreboard

Public records.
A clearer comparison.

For Memphis residents

Promised vs. Delivered Memphis Scoreboard

Public PILOT filings and compliance reports organized into a Memphis tax incentive deal scoreboard.

$5 Buy
Not on sale right now

Reading the evidence

A missing report
is not a result.

Delivery data can be missing, late or self-reported by companies. A useful scoreboard makes those limits visible rather than turning gaps into certainty.

Where do the records come from?

The Memphis scoreboard is built from public PILOT filings and compliance reports. PILOTs are the tax incentive deals handled through EDGE in Memphis.

What if delivery data is missing?

Missing records count as findings. They should be identified as missing—not treated as proof that jobs were delivered, or that they were not.

Is company-reported data the whole story?

No. Delivery data is often self-reported. The purpose of matching filings and compliance reports is to make the comparison inspectable, including the limits of the available evidence.

The promise is public.
The proof should be, too.

See the Memphis Scoreboard
Made with MadeThis